I always enjoyed the Dixie Chicks music. I have several of their CDs. As many know, Natalie Maines made a derogatory remark about President Bush during a concert in London. This remark not only caused boycotts, loss of money but also death threats to their families.
I was one that really wanted to buy their album "Home" at that time but could not bring myself to do so after that slanderous incident.
FREEDOM OF SPEECH. Yes, America is the land of the FREE and the home of the brave.
Do individuals have rights to use the public forum to express their opinions? I know I don't like it. I don't like the fact that Kanye "gag me" West uses it, and the Sarandon/ Robbins duo abuse it. Ms. Barbra Streisand and Mr. Alec Baldwin have still not moved out of country as they had promised if Bush was re-elected. What is up with that?
I really am torn. There is a very fine line sometimes between Freedom of Speech and slander. Where should the line be drawn if any line is to be drawn?
Am I not doing the same thing by writing this entry? No, I don't have stardom to increase the spread of my opinions (and believe me I have many and share them often), but I am still stating them on a public forum.
So, I sit here torn. How far does the Freedom of speech carry us?
As far as the Dixie Chicks, I may or may not buy their new album. I dislike their views because they are not the same as mine. I know it is not right to do so but I am merely human. The video .Dixie Chicks Video is their reply song to the incident. Not a bad song and it definitely got me thinking.
Posts
5 comments:
It's sad that you could not buy their "Home" cd because of their political views. It sounds like you like their music so why not continue to listen to something you like? That cd, I have and it is very good.
We only live fo awhile. I mean life is short. People will always express themselves and people will always disagree. That's what makes each person a person.
As for FREE speech. It's not FREE. If you want it and you speak out so the world can here you. Than most likly you pay a price and then keep paying; as the new single "Not Ready To Make Nice" from the Dixie Chicks says.
SOME would say it was "SLANDER"(The oral utterance or spreading of a falsehood harmful to another's reputation.). What it really was, was a person in an entertainment fashion spoke what she was feeling towards not having all the answers. Feeling frustrated about the way things were moving in the country she lived in. Natalie Maines spoke only 15 words "Just so you know, we're ashamed the President of the United States is from Texas". It was not an planned "attack" on the President. Should she have said it that way and in another country. Probably not. But that does not stop me from enjoying their music.
My preacher is very conservative, but that does not stop me from going to church.
I find it hard as a young adult to know certain things can be avoided. I find it foolish and stupid for any body in any faith, culture, or political position to sit for 7 MINUTES while "our" country is being attacked. I find it hard to believe while so many Americans are standing up and helping out with the Katrina Relief that "our" President is playing guitar. Or our Vice-President shooting quail or other citizens on VACATION!? I find it hard to be proud of our President and where we are heading. What will all of our futures be like? I understand I don't know all the facts and what exactly is going on, but whole heartedly find it hard to say to anyone that everything is fine and that what our President is saying and acting upon is correct and that I trust what our elected politicians are doing. Do I feel safe? Not one bit. Do I support our Troops? Of course. Do I feel that we need to get them home? Yes, right now! Do I feel our country needs to be healed and secure from inside out? Yes, right now!
Is this an opportunity for people who have voices to speak out and ask questions? Yes! Is it right to not be proud of our President? Yes, people are entitled to their opinions. Is it right to publicly say " I am not proud of our President"? It hurts to feel it, and it hurts to say it but yes it is right.
I AM AN AMERICAN AND PROUD TO BE LIVING IN A COUNTRY WHERE I CAN SAY WHAT I FEEL/BELIEVE.
I AM SAD THAT THE COUNTRY IS NOT SAFE. I AM SAD PEOPLE WITH THEIR OWN DREAMS ARE DYING FOR OUR PROTECTION, IN ORDER FOR US TO ACHIEVE OURS. I AM TERRIFIED WHERE THIS COUNTRY WILL BE IN 10 YEARS.
From this moment on, I will stand for what I believe and not back down from what my heart tells me. I will get involved with political parties that do the same. I will vote and spread my own word. I will get involved in my community and help out as much as possible. I will not sit for another 7 MINUTES without acting upon improving my own life, someone else's life, or helping our country where my loved ones live, where I live.
Thank you for your comment.
I have been thinking a lot about freedom of speech and the fact that just because I don't agree or like something, doesn't mean it is wrong.
I am known as a very straight forward individual. I speak my mind and am often told that that is what people love about me. One knows where they stand with me. i never hold back.
So, Yes, I was wrong in judging them. I still don't like what Natalie said but it is her freedom and right to do so.
Yes, I do like their music. I will probably buy an album in the future. I am also a stubborn person and once I am over my lil fit then I might get back to the enjoyment that their music provides me :)
Well, I think it is great you know who you are and what you stand for.
I love the Dixie Chicks and always have. I love them even more now becuase they are also true to themselves and does no let the industry walk over them or their own character. Sure their views may be different, but I think it is so cool they have keyed into whats important to them. I feel they are in touch with the spirt. They are not fake or try to be what they are not. A great example of what a person should be in my opinon.
You posted:
"I speak my mind and am often told that that is what people love about me.'
People say that about as well. And people I know have also said that about the Dixie Chicks.
Perhaps we are all very similar. We all want a voice. Sometimes it is easier to be heard when you are a celeb but anyone can be heard with the proper foundation of their own faith and willingness.
On another note:
I am adopted as well.
Well, I think it is great you know who you are and what you stand for.
I love the Dixie Chicks and always have. I love them even more now becuase they are also true to themselves and does no let the industry walk over them or their own character. Sure their views may be different, but I think it is so cool they have keyed into whats important to them. I feel they are in touch with the spirt. They are not fake or try to be what they are not. A great example of what a person should be in my opinon.
You posted:
"I speak my mind and am often told that that is what people love about me.'
People say that about me as well. And people I know have also said that about the Dixie Chicks.
Perhaps we are all very similar. We all want a voice. Sometimes it is easier to be heard when you are a celeb but anyone can be heard with the proper foundation of their own faith and willingness.
On another note:
I am adopted as well.
DIXIE CHICKS
TAKING THE LONG WAY
TRACK BY TRACK
1. The Long Way Around
Emily: That's a journey song, about the different stages in our lives. A recap of where we've been, where we're going - and it was nice to remind ourselves of all that.
Natalie: We've always written songs that are about other people. It's so much harder to put yourself out there and be honest with your emotions and your beliefs, but the songs are so much better and mean so much more when you can let yourself be vulnerable.
2. Easy Silence
Martie: We didn't set out to write a lot of love songs, but we're all probably in the best place we've ever been with our mates.
Natalie: There's also a bit of political commentary in there, from my point of view. I had to get a lot of other things off my chest before I could be nice and sentimental. Even when we tried to write a sweet song, there was always a little dig at somebody.
Martie: One of the challenges for me was that the songs we were writing weren't necessarily calling for the traditional kind of fiddling that I am used to doing on our records. The orchestrated approach really pushed me to dig back into my training and remember how to play and write with those sensibilities. Rick really encouraged me to think differently in this respect and not feel limited.
3. Not Ready To Make Nice
Emily: The stakes were definitely higher on that song. We knew it was special because it was so autobiographical, and we had to get it right. We've all gone through so many emotions about the incident. We talked for days with Dan before putting pen to paper, and he really helped get inside our heads and put these feelings out. And once we had this song done, it freed us up to do the rest of the album without that burden.
Martie: We had reached a point where we were laughing a lot about it, and people didn't really know how far it had gone. I realized I had suppressed a lot about the death threat. It all came flooding back in the process of writing this song, I think we all realized just how painful it had been for us.
Natalie: We tried to write about the incident a few times, but you get nervous that you're being too preachy or too victimized or too nonchalant. Dan came in with an idea that was some kind of concession, more 'can't we all just get along?' and I said, nope, I can't say that, can't do it. And we talked about it, and he said, what about "I'm not ready to make nice?" From the outside, normal people really weren't aware of how bizarre and absurd it got. Dan was really good at cluing in to that, saying something that didn't back down, but still had a vulnerability to it. This album was therapy. To write these songs allowed me to find peace with everything and move on.
4. Everybody Knows
Natalie: I find the psychology of celebrity very interesting; the things people are willing to sacrifice to be famous. I think it comes from a sad place. Some are grounded and can keep it in perspective, and some let it take over.
Emily: It's a soap opera, something for people to watch that's bigger than life. And the people who are in the middle of it love that. They want to be perceived as being larger than life. It's like watching "Richie Rich" or "Silver Spoons."
Martie: I'm very proud that when Brad and Jennifer broke up, I didn't know for a month!
Natalie: Sometimes you do feel more claustrophobic. I've definitely become more reclusive and anti-social and suspicious of people, which sucks, but it does come with it.
5. Bitter End
Emily: That started when Martie came in with a little Celtic fiddle riff, just like two notes.
Martie: I'd been listening to the Pogues a lot, and I just started from a drone and a waltz time feel. It was hard at first writing with people you don't know, how much you're willing to put out there and risk getting shot down. We spent long hours just talking with these people, talking about life, collaborating on what we wanted to say
Natalie: It's a lot of hours to spend with somebody if you don't have much in common. These writers are so good, they are constantly questioning if a song is the best it can be.
Emily: Gary Louris is just so melodic - and he's really good at singing nonsense words to the melodies, and then ideas just come out of that.
6. Lullaby
Emily: That was last song that was written for the album. We felt like we said everything we wanted to say, it was time to write a song about our kids.
Natalie: It's a song that you're really going to get and is going to make you cry if you have kids. If you're a teenager, I guess you can skip over it!
One thing that's cool about being a musician is that things live forever, so our kids will always have this as a gift to them.
7. Lubbock or Leave It
Emily: We'd seen a documentary called "The Education of Shelby Knox," which was about a girl - she was 16 at the time, very religious - trying to get Lubbock to teach sex education in the schools. And Lubbock has one of the highest rates of teen pregnancy and STDs in the US, so it really showed what happens when you keep this information away from people. Lubbock is also one of the last hold-out radio stations that still won't play us, and of course Natalie is from Lubbock, so she has personal experience with the box that a small town can keep you in.
Natalie: It's not just about Lubbock, but about any small, hypocritical town. Mike was asking me for all the details - the stores, streets and I came up with this long list of names. We talked about the irony of having a big painting of Buddy Holly at the airport -that his face is the last thing you see before getting on a plane! I do feel bad for my family who’s still there and has to defend me - after everything they already went through, to have to do it again.
8. Silent House
Natalie: This song is about my grandmother who has Alzheimer's. It's about walking through her house, that she no longer lives in. Packing up a house, having all those familiar feelings and passing those wonderful memories on to others.
Emily: Martie and I also had a grandfather who had dementia, and you realize that it's up to you to remember them the way they were, because you're going to be a witness to their life. That's one of my favorites on the album. It's kind of a dark horse - it's long, it takes a lot of patience, but I really grew to like it.
Natalie: Even though this song is about our experiences, almost everyone has been touched by something like this. The other writers were all very generous and understood what we needed to say.
9. Favorite Year
Martie: I had an idea for a song where the person knows in their heart that a relationship wasn't right, but still wants the other person to look back on it as the best time in their life. I think I was wished that that’s how my ex husband looked back on our 5 years together, but I know that's not the case. But hey, you can make it true in a song, right?
Natalie: I had just watched "The Big Chill," so that's what I was visualizing. People who were so in love when they were really young, and you really think you're going to spend the rest of your lives together, but then life just takes turns.
Emily: Sheryl Crow worked out the chord progression. We worked on this song together when we were recording "Home."
Natalie: We felt an instant connection to Sheryl, she's very real and funny, easy to talk to and open about herself.
10. Voice Inside My Head
Martie: This one was hard for Natalie. It took a long time for her to feel like she could sing this song and really own it. It's a very heavy subject matter and it took us a while to get it right.
Natalie: It’s one that didn’t come together until the very end. Rick was instrumental in making the sound really work for this song.
11. I Like It
Natalie: The day we wrote “I like It” with Gary we were looking just to write a rock song with a great hook. What I like most about this song is all the layers of harmonies. It was one of those songs that we got to try things vocally, that we had never done before.
12. Baby Hold On
Emily: That's a song touching on where we are in our lives and our relationships, trying to get your partner to be Number One in your life and putting the focus back on your marriage, as opposed to just being mom and dad. Kind of a "where are we now" look at married life.
Martie: I thought we'd write more about our families than we did. We're really good friends, but we don't always talk a lot about our personal lives - maybe out of not wanting to burden the others, or even just to keep a bit of privacy.
13. So Hard
Martie: That song touches on the issue of infertility, which Emily and I both had to deal with. I think we feel a responsibility to break down some of these barriers - it's much more of a common problem than people realize. Someone the other day asked me if twins ran in my family. When I told them I did in vitro they said, "Oh, so you took the easy way." I couldn't believe they said that.
Emily: We both got pregnant through in vitro fertilization, and people usually get all freaked out when we tell them that. I don't find it a stigma at all - people need to start talking about it, because it feels almost epidemic. And it's so wonderful that we have this technology.
14. I Hope
Emily: Keb Mo was one of the last writers we wrote with, and it was so nice and so comfortable working with him. With what he's been through and where he grew up, it's important to him to write positive, uplifting songs.
Natalie: On the other hand, he wasn't afraid to get political, and this ultimately turned out to be a pretty serious song. Hopeful and positive, but serious.
Post a Comment